Hot start not enough in second round loss to Wildcats

By Chase Benton on Nov. 21, 2026 in Men's Soccer

MARION, Ind. – Both teams came out firing in the ranked heavyweight slugfest between No. 22 Concordia University, Nebraska Men’s Soccer and No. 5 Indiana Wesleyan University on Saturday (Nov. 21). The Bulldogs scored first, but the Wildcats responded with two unanswered goals to claim a 2-1 victory. Niko Nareike became the second goal-scorer in Concordia history at the NAIA National Tournament.

First-year Head Coach Bernie Ochoa and company finished their 2026 campaign with a 14-5-1 record.

“First and foremost, I'm just proud of the boys,” Ochoa said. “They've had an amazing season. This game doesn't take away from the historic season they've had and everything they've done this year. I think we've had a really great year, both on and off the field. We never gave up. We didn't sit back. We kept fighting and creating opportunities. At the end of the day, they capitalized on their chances, and we just didn't create enough clear opportunities to get that equalizer or potentially win the game.”

The showdown didn’t disappoint from the opening whistle as both goalkeepers made diving saves in the opening minutes of the contest.

In the 14th minute, the Bulldogs earned a corner kick**, and** Joe McCarroll stepped up to deliver the set piece. McCarroll’s kick bent toward the back post**, where the 6-foot-5 Nareike rose above the defenders and directed a header into the net to give Concordia the early advantage**. The Frankfurt, Germany, native sprinted toward the bench in celebration after netting his fifth goal of the season.

Second-round host Indiana Wesleyan refused to back down, responding with two goals in a 10-minute span. Mariano Chaves and Dennis Otieno each found the back of the net, propelling IWU into the lead before the halftime break.

In the second half, the Wildcats generated early scoring opportunities, but momentum shifted toward the Bulldogs down the stretch. Concordia controlled possession for much of the final 15 minutes, searching for the equalizer, but the breakthrough never came.

Indiana Wesleyan held an 18-12 advantage in total shots, but Concordia matched the Wildcats with eight shots on goal apiece. CUNE edged IWU in corner kicks, 4-3, while the Wildcats committed eight fouls to the Dawgs’ 13. Goalkeeper Florian Quast collected six saves between the posts.

Niko Nareike spearheaded the Bulldog attack with four shots, including two on goal. Kai Olbrich and Elijah Fulton followed with three attempts apiece, placing two each on frame. Connor Robbins and Jasper Hofland added one shot on goal each.

Sean Stratman and Michael Wyvill helped anchor the Concordia defensive effort, combining with their teammates to challenge the Wildcats' attack, particularly in the second half.

Indiana Wesleyan will advance to the final site in Orange Beach, Ala., to face Grand View University (Iowa) in the round of 16.

Concordia finished the season as GPAC regular-season champion and earned the program’s first NAIA National Tournament victory. Stratman and Nareike became the first two Bulldogs to score in national tournament play. A CUNE Men’s Soccer single-season record, the Dawgs scored 63 goals in 2026.

Coach Ochoa continued, “I told the boys that they've made this a historic and special year for me. First years aren't usually the best years, but this has been an amazing year, and I couldn't have asked for anything else. I'm excited for the future with the guys coming back and the players I'm hoping to bring in. I want to continue building the strong program we have, stay at the top and compete on this stage year in and year out.”